A 38 year old woman presented to ED with a painful left wrist, having injured it in a fall whilst walking her Labrador. As her dog took chase after a cat, she fell heavily onto her left hand, which was holding the lead at the time.
On presentation there was marked swelling of the left wrist, particularly on the volar aspect, and on examination it was noted that the ulna styloid prominence was absent. The patient demonstrated close to full range of palmar flexion and dorsiflexion at the wrist, but the forearm was fixed in supination.
X-ray studies of the left wrist were obtained:
The patient was subsequently diagnosed with an isolated volar ulna dislocation of her left wrist and the dislocation was reduced with propofol sedation in the emergency department.
A careful clinical examination is key in the diagnosis of volar ulna dislocation. Some features that may be observed include the absence of the ulna styloid prominence, volar fullness at the ulnar aspect of the wrist and narrowing of the wrist. Unfortunately in the acute setting, swelling and haemorrhage may hinder detection of these signs, making diagnosis difficult. Upon movement, pronation may be impossible (with the forearm locked in supination), restricted, painful, or merely uncomfortable, while the range of palmar flexion and dorsiflexion at the wrist is often normal. Ulna nerve symptoms may also be present, such as paraesthesia of the ring and small fingers.
On the same rainy day a second distal radioulnar joint injury (DRUJ) attended the department. Naturally this was no longer seen as a difficult to diagnose injury and an effective treatment plan was immediately instituted.
Those of you with superstitious tendencies will be glad to know that we abided by the ‘rule of threes‘ and actively reviewed all the weekends radiological imaging for evidence of the ‘missed dislocation’.
Content in the knowledge that one had not been missed this report ‘closes the loop’ on the ‘see one, do one, teach one‘ QI cycle.
Biplanar radiography is indicated to aid in the diagnosis of volar ulna dislocation, with anteroposterior and lateral X-rays needed for an adequate assessment. HoweverUnfortunately, pain and restricted range of movement can limit a patient’s ability to hold the necessary positions to obtain X-rays; countless cases have been reported in which this injury has been missed. Just 10-20 degrees of forearm rotation can obscure the view of the distal radius and ulna in a lateral radiograph highlighting the importance of a true lateral radiograph. This can be obtained with the elbow flexed to 90 degrees, with the arm placed by the side of the chest, forearm in neutral position, and the x-ray beam centred between the two styloid processes. In a normal true lateral x-ray, the distal radius is superimposed on the ulna, whereas in volar ulna dislocation, the distal ulna is displaced anteriorly in relation to the radiocarpal mass. For the anteroposterior x-ray, the shoulder must be abducted to 90 degrees and elbow flexed at 90 degrees, with the forearm, wrist and hand resting on the cassette. Normally, a 2-3mm space exists between the distal radius and ulna, but in volar ulna dislocation there is an overlap of the distal radius and ulna.
In cases where radiography is inconclusive or difficult to execute, computed tomography (CT) of the distal radio-ulnar joint should be employed, accurately demonstrating the dislocation at any position of forearm rotation.
In most cases of isolated volar ulna dislocation, the injury is reduced under general anaesthetic by forceful manipulation of the joint, using manual pressure on the ulna in a medial and dorsal direction, and hyperpronation of the forearm. Occasionally, it may be required to reduce the dislocation with an open procedure, particularly when the diagnosis has been delayed or in cases where the ulna is locked under the radius. The arm must then be immobilised for 6 weeks in full pronation in an above-elbow cast with physiotherapy required to regain best range of movement in the wrist joint.
Isolated volar dislocation of the ulna head was first described by Pierre-Joseph Desault in 1777, with occasional cases reported since. It was thought that the injury was caused by hypersupination of the forearm on a fixed hand, a theory that has since been supported by various clinicians and seen to be the most common mechanism of volar ulna dislocation. Two other less common mechanisms include a direct dorsally applied force to the distal ulna, and a pronation injury to the hand in which the forearm is fixed. Incidently, this type of dislocation has been associated with sports such as gymnastics, weight-lifting and rugby, in which increased forces are applied to the heel of the palm, transmitting pressure onto the radio-ulnar joint. Injuries of this nature tend to give rise to damage to the stabilizing structures of the distal radio-ulna joint, such as the ulnar collateral ligament, triangular fibrocartilage, anterior and posterior radioulnar ligaments and pronator quadratus.
Isolated volar ulna dislocation is a very rare injury which is often misdiagnosed. Without a detailed history of the mechanism of injury and a thorough examination, it is frequently dismissed as an insignificant wrist injury, requiring a high index of suspicion from clinicians. Difficulty in obtaining adequate x-rays can also hinder accurate diagnosis, with CT being the gold standard for ruling out dislocation. If untreated, volar ulna dislocation may lead to significant morbidity, with a significant restriction in forearm pronation.
- LITFL – An unusual wrist injury
- Mittal R, Kulkarni R, Subsposh SY, & Giannoudis PV (2004). Isolated volar dislocation of distal radioulnar joint: how easy to miss! European journal of emergency medicine 11 (2), 113-6 [PMID 15028903]
- Binu P, Sreekanth T, Sreekanth R. Distal radioulnar joint injuries. Indian J Orthop. 2012 Sep-Oct; 46(5): 493–504. [PMC 3491781]
- Tsai PC, Paksima N. The Distal Radioulnar Joint. Bulletin of the NYU Hospital for Joint Diseases 2009;67(1):90-6 [PDF]
- Tang YK, Cheung JPY, Fung B. A Rare Combination: Locked Volar Distal Radio-ulnar Joint dislocation with Isolated volar Capsule Rupture. Hand Surgery, Vol. 19, No. 3 (2014) 413–417 © World Scientific Publishing Company . DOI: 10.1142/S0218810414720277
- Bouri F, Fuad M, Elsayed Abdolenour A. Locked volar distal radioulnar joint dislocation. Int J Surg Case Rep. 2016 Mar 22;22:12-14. doi: 10.1016/j.ijscr.2016.03.012 [PMID 27016647]
- Kumar A, Iqbal MJ. Missed Isolated Volar Dislocation of the Distal Radio-Ulnar Joint: A Case Report. The Journal of Emergency Medicine 1999. 17(5): 873-875. [PMID: 10499705]
- McMurray D, Muralikuttan K. Volar Displacement of the distal radio-ulnar joint without fracture: A case report and literature review. Injury Extra 2008. 39: 352-355. [Reference]
- Newman KJH, Koh CT. Volar dislocation of the ulna head: torn triangular fibrocartilage demonstrated on MRI scan. Injury 1994. 25: 259-261. [Reference]
- Quah C, Counsell A, Heasley R, Kocialkowski A. Isolated Volar dislocation of the distal radio-ulna joint: A case report and review of the literature. The Internet Journal of Orthopedic Surgery 2007. 7(2). [ISPUB Reference]
- Schiller MG, af Ekenstam F, Kirsch PT. Volar dislocation of the distal radio-ulnar joint. A case report. The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, American Volume 1991. 73: 617-619. [PMID: 2013605]
- Takami H, Takahashi S, Ando M. Isolated palmar dislocation of the distal radioulnar joint in a football player. Archives of Orthopaedics and Trauma Surgery 2000. 120: 598-600. [PMID: 11110145]
Research and author credit: Keira Baker