Sternoclavicular joint dislocation is a relatively uncommon injury that can be easily missed or misdiagnosed. Bilateral posterior sternoclavicular joint dislocation is even rarer still…
The importance in determining the direction of dislocation is emphasised by the dichotomy of management. Hence, a thorough history and examination, especially looking for evidence of compression of retrosternal structures, is paramount. Specialised sternoclavicular X-ray views should be supplemented by CT/MRI if clinical suspicion is high. Posterior dislocations necessitate prompt orthopedic referral.
A 30 year old man presented to ED with bilateral “shoulder pain” after a quad bike accident. Having taken a corner at high speed, he feel from the bike landing on his right shoulder and was crushed by the bike landing on his left shoulder.
On presentation, ABCs were intact. No dysphonia, dysphagia or dyspnoea.
Both right and left shoulders were dislocated anteriorly and were relocated at triage.
There was swelling and tenderness over both sternoclavicular joints and the patient was unable to abduct either shoulder actively despite glenohumeral enlocation. Passive movement of the shoulders was limited by pain “over the collarbone”, although the clavicles themselves were only tender near their junction with the sternum. Specifically, the AC joints and humerus were non-tender and arm neurovascular status was normal.
Initial Chest X-ray was performed and reported as normal
However in light of the high clinical suspicion for sternoclavicular joint injury; continued anterior chest pain and failure in shoulder abduction special plain film tomography views of both SC joints was performed:
There is widening of the right sternoclavicular joint when compared to the left side. This appearance is suspicious for subluxation/dislocation. There is probable subtle widening of the left sternoclavicular joint as well. Several well-corticated bone ossicles are noted in the vicinity of the sternoclavicular joints bilaterally.
This was confirmed on CT scan:
Superior dislocation of bilateral sternoclavicular joints. Associated fracture of the left 1st rib anteriorly noted.
Anatomy of the sternoclavicular joint
- The sternoclavicular joint is a diarthodial saddle-type joint which provides a pivot for the shoulder girdle on the trunk.
- The joint capsule is reinforced anterioposteriorly by the anterior and posterior sternoclavicular ligaments. Superomedially the joint is reinforced by the interclavicular ligament which joins both the upper boarder of both clavicles to the suprasternal notch.
- The clavicle is also bound to the first costal cartilage and the first rib by the costoclavicular ligament.
Sir Astley Paston Cooper (23 Aug 1768 – 12 Feb 1841)
An English surgeon and pioneer in experimental surgery. He was the first to tie the abdominal aorta in treating an aneurysm (1817), among various other operations he performed successfully at a time before antiseptic procedures. He was devoted to the study and teaching of anatomy, and is said to have dissected daily throughout his career.
In 1820 he excised and infected sebaceous cyst from the scalp of King George IV. He was appointed sergeant surgeon to George IV, William IV and Queen Victoria. He was elected President of the Royal College of Surgeons on two occasions (1827 &1836).
Sir Astley Cooper is credited with the first report of thisentity in ‘A treatise on dislocations and on fractures of the joints‘ in 1824. Approximately 120 cases of posterior sternoclavicular joint (SCJ) dislocation have been documented in the medical literature since it was first described, a statistic which underlies its relative rarity. Despite this statistic, emergency physicians should be familiarwith the condition the mechanismof injury and physical findings and the potentially life-threatening injuries.
- Sternoclavicular dislocations account for 3% of all shoulder girdle injuries.
- 95% of SCJ dislocations are unilateral and anterior dislocations are far more common than posterior dislocations due to the weaker anterior sternoclavicular ligament (ratio 9:1). Bilateral superior dislocations, as in the case above, are rarely described.
Mechanism of Injury
- Dislocations of the SCJ generally occur following a fall on the outstretched hand or a direct blow to the shoulder. Sporting injuries and motor vehicle accidents account for the most causes of SCJ dysfunction. However, they can also occur without any history of injury.
- Patients commonly present with pain and swelling in the proximal sternum and sternoclavicular region. The pain will be exacerbated by lateral shoulder compression, arm movements, deep breathing or coughing.
- Patients often laterally flex their neck towards the affected side to relieving pressure on the SCJ. Asymmetry is best appreciated when viewed from above the patient’s head.
- Additional symptoms include dysphonia, dysphagia or dyspnoea.
- Plain X-ray: standard views may not provide a definitive diagnosis. Alternate views such as ‘serendipity view’ (40-degree cephalic tilt) may provide more information.
- CTA or MRA to determine direction of dislocation and potential for vascular compromise. A contrast study is required for definitive evaluation of surrounding structures.
Many complications have been reported in the literature related to retrosternal (posterior) dislocation of the medial end of the clavicle including:
- Subclavian compression and laceration
- Mediastinal compression
- Oesophageal rupture
- Myocardial conduction abnormalities
- Brachial plexopathy
- Tracheal tear
- Thoracic outlet syndrome
Simple sprain of the SCJ
- Patients will complain of mild to moderate pain and there will be no joint instability on clinical examination.
- Conservative treatment with ice, analgesia, shoulder sling for immobility will lead to complete recovery in 1 week.
- Subluxation of the SCJ will require the application of a clavicular splint or sling for 3 to 6 weeks
Anterior SCJ Dislocations
- Anterior sternoclavicular dislocations are usually managed nonoperatively.
- The clavicle often stabilises in its subluxed position, with asymmetrical ventral protrusion of the affected side. The arm should be rested in a sling which will assist in the reduction of pain. Patients generally experience a good pain-free functional outcome at 2-3 weeks. Very rare complications include chronic pain, periarticular calcifications with ankylosis and progressive deformity.
- Closed reduction may be indicated in rare circumstances where the patient is engaged in strenuous upper limb activities causing a painful SCJ. It is however, often unsuccessful. The application of direct pressure over the medial end of the clavicle may also reduce the joint.
Posterior SCJ Dislocations
- Posterior sternoclavicular dislocations should always be reduced in theatre because of the associated risk to intrathoracic and superior mediastinal structures.
Example of a Unilateral Posterior Sternoclavicular Dislocation
Methods of reduction
The initial treatment of choice is a closed reduction. Various methods have been described:
- Classical: Patient positioned supine with a towel/sandbag between scapulae. Sedation is administered and traction is applied to the abducted arm with simultaneous extension. This has an 80% success rate.
- Buckerfield and Castle: While shoulders are pushed posteriorly by an assistant, the ipsilateral arm is adducted against the torso and caudal traction is applied.
- Towel Clip: Anterior traction force can be applied to clavicle by percutaneously applied towel clip, often used with one of the above methods.
- A figure of eight sling is applied after the reduction for 4-6 weeks to allow for ligamentous healing.
If the SCJ becomes chronically unstable or if closed reduction is unsuccessful, then open reduction is indicated.
Traumatic sternoclavicular joint dislocation is an uncommon condition whose diagnosis is often missed. The importance in determining the direction of dislocation is emphasised by the dichotomy of management. The posterior version of this dislocation has been associated with multiple complications and owing to the rarity of this injury, there is a relative lack of familiarity with the diagnosis, surgical anatomy and treatment options. [Reference]
A thorough history and examination, especially looking for evidence of compression of retrosternal structures, is paramount. Specialised sternoclavicular X-ray views should be supplemented by CT/MRI if clinical suspicion is high. Posterior dislocations necessitate prompt orthopedic referral.
Saltzman, M., Mercer, D., Bertelsen, A., Warme, W., & Matsen, III, F. (2009). Bilateral posterior sternoclavicular dislocations Radiology Case Reports, 4 (1) DOI: 10.2484/rcr.v4i1.256
- Jacques B. Jougon, MD, Denis J. Lepront, MD, Claire E. H. Dromer, M. Posterior Dislocation of the Sternoclavicular Joint Leading to Mediastinal Compression. [Reference]
- Hoekzema N. Torchia M. Adkins M Cassivi SD. Posterior sternoclavicular joint dislocation [Reference]
- Mirza AH, Alam K, Ali A Posterior sternoclavicular dislocation in a rugby player as a cause of silent vascular compromise: a case report. Br J Sports Med. 2005 May;39(5):e28. [Reference]
- Asplund C, Pollard ME. Posterior sternoclavicular joint dislocation in a wrestler. Mil Med. 2004 Feb;169(2):134-6. [Reference]
- Wirth MA, Rockwood CA Jr. Acute and Chronic Traumatic Injuries of the Sternoclavicular Joint.J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 1996 Oct;4(5):268-278. [Reference]
- Brinker MR, Bartz RL, Reardon PR, Reardon MJ. A method for open reduction and internal fixation of the unstable posterior sternoclavicular joint dislocation. J Orthop Trauma. 1997 Jul;11(5):378-81. [Reference]
- Saltzman, M., Mercer, D., Bertelsen, A., Warme, W., & Matsen, III, F. (2009). Bilateral posterior sternoclavicular dislocations Radiology Case Reports, 4 (1) DOI: 10.2484/rcr.v4i1.256
- O’Connor PA. Nölke L. O’Donnell A. Maha Lingham A. Retrosternal dislocation of the clavicle associated with a traumatic pneumothorax [Reference]
- Cooper A. A treatise on dislocations and on fractures of the joints. In: Longman, Hurst, Orme, Brown, Green, eds. London, 1824:359
An old Scotch physician, for whom I had a great respect, and whom I frequently met professionally in the city, used to say, as we were entering the patient’s room together, ‘Weel, Mister Cooper, we ha’ only twa things to keep in meend, and they’ll searve us for here and herea’ter; one is always to have the fear of the Laird before our ees; that ‘ill do for herea’ter; and t’other is to keep your booels open, and that will do for here.’ – Sir Astley Cooper
Research Credit – Dr Andrew Toffoli