aka Toxicology Conundrum 036
A 31 year-old man and his 27 year-old wife present to the emergency department a few hours after eating at a seafood restaurant. In addition to nausea and vomiting, they both complain of altered sensation affecting their hands and feet. Both patients were previously well.
Questions
Q1. Based on the limited clinical information, what types of seafood poisoning syndromes could be affecting these patients?
Numerous types of seafood poisoning can cause symptoms of gastroenteritis and paraesthesiae (abnormal skin sensations like ‘pins and needles’)
The differential diagnosis includes:
- Amnestic shellfish poisoning
- Ciguatera poisoning
- Neurotoxic shellfish poisoning
- Palytoxin poisoning
- Paralytic shellfish poisoning
- Tetrodotoxin poisoning
Other types of seafood food poisoning cause gastroenteritis, but do not specifically cause paraesthesiae:
- diarrhetic shellfish poisoning
- scombroid poisoning
- bacterial food poisoning
Paraesthesiae could also be caused by secondary alkalemia:
- hyperventilation-induced respiratory alkalosis, or
- vomiting-induced metabolic alkalosis
Q2. If one of the patients complains that the cold bed rails in the emergency department are “burning hot”, what would be the likely diagnosis and why?
Ciguatera poisoning
Hot-cold reversal, better termed cold allodynia, is considered almost pathognomonic of ciguatera poisoning (other dinoflagellate toxins such as palytoxin may mimic ciguatoxin). The phenomenon is probably not a true reversal of temperature sensation, rather pain sensation is altered such that cold is experienced as a burning pain. The mechanism for this is obscure.
Ciguatoxin CTX1B
Q3. What toxin is responsible for each of the following seafood poisoning syndromes?
- Amnestic shellfish poisoning —
Domoic acid (stimulates glutamate receptors)- Ciguatera poisoning —
Ciguatoxin (a family of toxins that cause sodium channel activation and the stimulation of cholinergic receptors)- Diarrhetic shellfish poisoning —
Various diarrhetic toxins: okadeic acid, azaspiracid, dinophysitoxins (and no, I didn’t make these words up…)- Neurotoxic shellfish poisoning —
Brevetoxin- Palytoxin poisoning —
Palytoxin/ clupetoxin (a potent vasoconstrictor that alters sodium and potassium flux across cell membranes)- Paralytic shellfish poisoning —
Saxitoxin (a potent sodium channel blocker that may be lethal in <1mg doses — a contaminated mussel may contain 20mg of saxitoxin!)- Scombroid poisoning —
Scombrotoxin (biogenic amines produced from histidine breakdown)- Tetrodotoxin poisoning —
Tetrodotoxin (sodium channel blocker)
Q4. What are the typical clinical features for each of the following seafood poisoning syndromes?
- Amnestic shellfish poisoning —
Gastroenteritis, mutism, myoclonus, headaches, seizures, coma.
Hypotension and bronchorrhea may occur.
Chronic peripheral neuropathies and memory impairment- Ciguatera poisoning —
Vomiting and watery diarrhoea, ‘hot-cold reversal’ (cold allodynia), headache, paraesthesiae of the mouth and extremities, pruritis, myalgias, weakness; rarely seizures and respiratory arrest.
Chronic paraesthesiae, pruritis and neuropsychiatric symptoms last for years in some patients- Diarrhetic shellfish poisoning —
Vomiting, abdominal cramps, and severe diarrhoea- Neurotoxic shellfish poisoning —
Gastroenteritis, ataxia, paresthesiae, seizures- Paralytic shellfish poisoning —
Gastroenteritis, paraesthesiae, ataxia, respiratory paralysis- Palytoxin poisoning —
Gastroenteritis, paresthesiae, severe muscle spasms, rhabdomyolysis, hypertension, seizures, respiratory distress, myocardial injury- Scombroid poisoning —
Gastroenteritis, flushed skin, hypotension, urticaria, wheezing- Tetrodotoxin poisoning —
Vomiting, paraesthesiae, muscle twitching, diaphoresis, bradycardia, flaccid paralysis, respiratory paralysis
Q5. Eating what type of seafood typically causes each of the following seafood poisoning syndromes?
- Amnestic shellfish poisoning —
mussels, clams, anchovies- Ciguatera poisoning —
reef fish such as: barracuda, red snapper, grouper- Diarrhetic shellfish poisoning —
bivalve mollusks- Neurotoxic shellfish poisoning —
bivalve mollusks, whelks- Palytoxin poisoning —
parrotfish, crabs, mackerel, sardines- Paralytic shellfish poisoning —
bivalve shellfish affected by ‘red tide’ dinoflagellates- Scombroid poisoning —
tuna, mahi-mahi, bonito, mackerel- Tetrodotoxin poisoning —
pufferfish, sunfish, porcupinefish, others…
Q6. How long after ingestion does the onset of clinical features of toxicity occur for each of the following seafood poisoning syndromes?
- Amnestic shellfish poisoning —
minutes to hours- Ciguatera poisoning —
1 to 6 hours (or longer in mild cases)- Diarrhetic shellfish poisoning —
30 minutes to 2 hours- Neurotoxic shellfish poisoning —
minutes to 3 hours- Palytoxin poisoning —
hours- Paralytic shellfish poisoning —
<30 minutes- Scombroid poisoning —
minutes to hours- Tetrodotoxin poisoning —
<1 hour
Q7. What is the ultimate source of toxin for most seafood poisoning syndromes?
Dinoflagellates
Dinoflagellates are tiny flagellated protists. They are marine plankton that are eaten by mollusks and fish. They produce various toxins that accumulate in the food chain, when one species eats another on a lower rung of the predatory ladder. For instance, the dinoflagellate Gambierdiscus toxicus produces ciguatoxin. Other dinoflagellates may form algal blooms called ‘red tides’, which are associated with outbreaks of shellfish poisoning.
The toxins that cause scombroid and tetrodotoxin poisoning are not produced by dinoflagellates.
Concerns have also been raised about the safety of eating fish given the accumulation of toxins such as mercury, dioxin and PCBs in the food chain. Overall, the health benefits of including fish in one’s diet exceeds any risks.
New dinoflagellate toxins will undoubtedly be discovered in the future — this post is cannot hope to be comprehensive.
Q8. How is the toxin that causes scombroid produced?
Scombrotoxin consists of histamine (and probably other biogenic amines) produced by the breakdown of histidine in the muscles of poorly refrigerated fish.
Hence the symptoms can mimic an allergic reaction.
The conversion of fish muscle histidine to histamine is enzymatically catalysed by histidine decarboxylase produced by the gram-negative bacterium Morganella morganii. This occurs at temperatures above 16C. Histamine is heat stable, so scombroid poisoning can occur even when poorly refrigerated fish has been properly cooked.
Q9. How is it possible that tetrodotoxin is found in species as diverse as a newt, the blue-ringed octopus and puffer fish?
Tetrodotoxin is produced by bacteria, such as Vibro alginolyticus, that coexist with many different animal species.
Tetrodotoxin is found in:
- fish — pufferfish, sunfish, angelfish.
- amphibians — toads and newts (aka tarichatoxin)
- invertebrates — ribbon worms, arrow worms, flatworms
- mollusks — blue-ringed octopus (aka maculotoxin), xanthid crabs, sea slugs
Tetrodotoxin
Q10. Is the taste of seafood resulting in seafood poisoning syndromes altered?
In most cases of seafood poisoning the taste of the seafood is not altered.
There are exceptions, such as the fish responsible for:
- scombroid poisoning — may taste peppery
- palytoxin poisoning — may taste bitter
Q11. Describe the management of toxic seafood poisoning, including specific therapies that may be beneficial for specific types of seafood poisoning.
As always, initial resuscitation and ongoing supportive care are the mainstays. Most cases are self-limiting and not life-threatening.
Resuscitation and supportive care
- intubation and ventilation may be required for respiratory depression, coma or seizure control
- fluid resuscitation for hypotension and/or shock resulting from gastroenteritis or cardiovascular toxicity
- bradycardia may require treatment with atropine (e.g. tetrodotoxin poisoning)
- benzodiazepines for seizure control
- antiemetics for nausea and vomiting
- analgesia for abdominal cramps or muscle pain
- observation for 6 hours to monitor for the delayed onset of symptoms
Decontamination
- not usually indicated
- activated charcoal may be given in potentially life-threatening seafood poisoning (e.g. following pufferfish ingestion)
Specific therapy may be required for:
- Scombroid poisoning —
Symptomatic treatment with antihistamines. Bronchodilators are rarely required.
Very rarely the presentation may mimic anaphylaxis requiring adrenaline.- Ciguatera poisoning —
Mannitol (0.5-1g/kg IV, ideally within 72 hours of symptom onset) is still recommended by some experts despite a double-blind randomised controlled trial that found no benefit*.
* this study did have flaws: most cases were given mannitol late, the subgroup analysis of those receiving mannitol early (within 24 hours) was underpowered and case diagnoses were not confirmed by toxin assays of fish samples.
Mannitol’s beneficial effects (if any) may be related to a decrease in neuronal edema, free radical scavenging or sodium/ potassium channel modulation. Mannitol will induce an osmotic diuresis and should only be administered following adequate rehydration of the patient.
Chronic neuropsychiatric symptoms may respond to fluoxetine, and neuropathic pain may respond to amitriptyline and/or gabapentin. The evidence base for these treatments is purely anecdotal.
Patients need to be aware of precipitants that may trigger a relapse — potential triggers include: ethanol, eating fish and other various other foods (including caffeine, nuts, chicken and pork), dehydration and over-exertion. Potential triggers should be avoided for 6 months following symptom resolution.
Fugu
Why do Pufferfish puff?
Educational documentary on Ciguatera Poisoning
References
- Brett MM. (2003) Food poisoning associated with biotoxins in fish and shellfish. Current Opinion in Infectious Diseases, 16(5), 461-5. PMID: 14501999
- Friedman MA, et al (2008). Ciguatera fish poisoning: treatment, prevention and management. Marine Drugs, 6 (3), 456-79 PMID: 19005579
- Lawrence DT, et al. (2007) Food poisoning. Emergency Medicine Clinics of North America, 25(2), 357. PMID: 17482025
- Mozaffarian D, Rimm EB. (2006) Fish intake, contaminants, and human health: evaluating the risks and the benefits. JAMA, 296(15), 1885-99. PMID: 17047219
- Olson, K. Poisoning and Drug Overdose (5th edition). McGraw-Hill, 2006.
- Schnorf H, Taurarii M, Cundy T. (2002) Ciguatera fish poisoning: a double-blind randomized trial of mannitol therapy. Neurology, 58(6), 873-80. PMID: 11914401
- Watkins SM, et al. (2008) Neurotoxic shellfish poisoning. Marine drugs, 6(3), 431-55. PMID: 19005578
About Chris Nickson
Had Lisa from the Maryland Poison Center on to talk about Ciguatera poisoning last year on the MedicCast as one of her regular Tox Tidbit segments on the show. It was very informative. However, I have to say that you have done a good job with the Q/A here. Keep it up, I’m looking forward to what you have next for us.
As a reluctant member of a keen angling family , I am often put on the spot on those Long fishing expeditions with questions such as ” what fish causes…?” “how does the pufferfish do…?”.
For this reason, I am particularly grateful for this article ,and in addition to flicking it to all of my fishing and sashimi friends, have actually printed it out and stuck it at the bottom of the tackle box for the next time we land a giant red snapper and feel a bit strange afterwards
Cheers Michelle1 -- hopefully you never have to make first hand use of it…
Happy angling,
Chris
Thanks, great info.