aka Neurological Mind-boggler 003
As promised here are some scenarios to try out Gates’ Brainstem Rules of 4 (helpful figures here):
Scenario 1
You are examining a patient with sudden onset left-sided weakness. These are your clinical examination findings:
- weakness of the left upper and lower limbs, with sparing of the face.
- tongue deviation to the right, with no ophthalmoplegia.
- loss of vibration and proprioception in the left upper and lower limbs.
Where is the lesion?
- weakness of the left upper and lower limbs, with sparing of the face:
motor (corticospinal pathway) localises the lesion to the contralateral medial brainstem
(sparing of the face (CN7) means the lesion must be below the upper pons)- tongue deviation to the right, with no ophthalmoplegia:
tongue deviation indicates CN12 involvement, localising the lesion to the ipsilateral medulla
(sparing of CN3 and CN6 means the midbrain and pons are not involved)- loss of vibration and proprioception in the left upper and lower limbs:
confirms localisation of the lesion to the contralateral medial brainstem
Site of the lesion: right medial medulla. Sometimes, due to the peculiar pattern of blood supply to the medulla, bilateral infarction may occur.
Scenario 2
You are examining a patient with sudden onset right-sided weakness. These are your clinical examination findings:
- weakness of the right face, upper and lower limbs.
- the left eye is turned “down and out” and the pupil is dilated.
Where is the lesion?
- weakness of the right face, upper and lower limbs:
motor (corticospinal pathway) localises the lesion to the contralateral medial brainstem
(involvement of the face means the lesion must be at or above the upper pons)- the left eye is turned “down and out” and the pupil is dilated:
CN3 involvement, localising the lesion to the ipsilateral midbrain
(sparing of CN6 and CN12 means the pons and medulla are not involved)
Site of the lesion: left medial midbrain. A CN3 palsy (from damage to the CN3 nerve fascicle) and contralateral hemiplegia is known as Weber’s syndrome (“basal” infarction) – which can be difficult to distinguish from ‘coning’ if you don’t have a CT scanner available.
Scenario 3
You are examining a patient with vertigo, vomiting, and nystagmus. These are your clinical examination findings:
- left-sided limb ataxia.
- left-sided alteration of pain and temperature on the face.
- left-sided ipsilateral Homer’s syndrome.
- right-sided alteration of pain and temperature affecting the arm and leg.
- dysarthria and decreased gag reflex on the left, with the palate pulling up on the right-side.
Where is the lesion?
- left-sided limb ataxia:
spinocerebellar pathway localises the lesion to the ipsilateral lateral brainstem.- left-sided alteration of pain and temperature on the face:
Sensory nucleus of the 5th cranial nerve localises the lesion to the ipsilateral lateral brainstem.- left-sided ipsilateral Homer’s syndrome:
Sympathetic pathway localises the lesion to the ipsilateral lateral brainstem.- right-sided alteration of pain and temperature affecting the arm and leg:
Spinothalamic pathway localises the lesion to the contralateral lateral brainstem.- dysarthria and decreased gag reflex on the left, with the palate pulling up on the right-side:
localises the lesion to the medulla affecting the ipsilateral CN9 and 10.
Site of the lesion: left lateral medulla. Also known as Wallenberg’s syndrome, caused by a left vertebral or left posterior inferior cerebellar artery occlusion (blood supply is variable to this region).
Scenario 4
You are examining a patient with right-sided deafness, that was preceded by tinnitus. These are your clinical examination findings:
- right-sided limb ataxia (predominantly affecting the right upper limb).
- right-sided facial numbness with loss of the corneal reflex.
- right-sided hemi-facial spasms.
Where is the lesion?
- right-sided limb ataxia (predominantly affecting the right upper limb):
spinocerebellar pathway localises the lesion to the ipsilateral lateral brainstem.- right-sided facial numbness with loss of the corneal reflex:
Sensory nucleus of the 5th cranial nerve localises the lesion to the ipsilateral lateral brainstem.- right-sided hemi-facial spasms:
the lesion involves the pons affecting the ipsilateral CN7.
Site of the lesion: The findings indicate a lesion affecting the right lateral pons with evidence of spinocerebellar involvement. In this case the lesion was not vascular in origin but in fact an example of a cerebropontine angle lesion – an acoustic neuroma (or schwannoma). This demonstrates the broader utility of Gates’ Brainstem Rules of 4.
References
- Gates, P. The rule of 4 of the brainstem: a simplified method for understanding brainstem anatomy and brainstem vascular syndromes for the non-neurologist. Internal Medicine Journal 2005; 35: 263-266 [pubmed]
- Goldberg, S. Clinical Neuroanatomy Made Ridiculously Simple. MedMaster Series, 2000 Edition. [betterworldbooks]
- Patten, J. Neurological Differential Diagnosis. Springer-Verlag, 1995 (2nd edition). [Google books preview]
‘Life in the Fast Lane’ links































Cheers from a med student who now understands brainstem lesions -- excellent diagram -- thanks for your efforts.
these problems are great, i passed it on to all my friends….real life saver during step 1 studying. thank you so much!!
This post is particularly helpful. After 30-40 minutes of using your blog posts, I have a significantly better understanding of brainstem lesions. Cheers.